At the beginning of the Bigfoot craze, Murphysboro, Illinois threw their cryptid hat in the ring.

At the dawn of the 21st century, an alleged time traveler burst onto the early message-board scene.

Though the mountain region isn’t traditionally known for its immortal undead, there is a tale of one particular vampire.

Pennsylvania’s saddest, ugliest, and somehow most adorable cryptid.

Fruit of the Loom, Darth Vader, The Berenstain Bears, Shazam.

Wyoming’s favorite cryptid, the jackalope, is admittedly a hard sell as far as the supernatural goes.

Back in 2000, one of the first viral “haunted” Ebay auctions listed an allegedly cursed painting.

The hodag made its national debut when one was supposedly captured alive and put on display at a county fair.

In Southwestern Connecticut, in a little village tucked into Monroe, there’s a legend of a local witch.

Back in 1966, dozens of UFO sightings swept the Ann Arbor, Michigan area.

Coming to you deep from Florida’s swamps is the Sunshine State’s favorite cryptid.

A relative newcomer to the cryptid fold, the chupacabra made its worldwide debut in 1995.

Centralia, Pennsylvania was a busy mining town until a fire of unclear origins started.

Absolutely adorable (as long as you have a fondness for walking pants).

Some say that a werewolf once lived in Georgia.

This lesser-known Bigfoot was, for a few weeks in 1972, the frenzied focus of locals and paranormal researchers alike.

The world has already considered the perils of facing 30-50 feral hogs.

What happens when a classical composer tries to best Beethoven?

On Labor Day of 1969, dozens of residents of Berkshire County, MA experienced extraordinary, widespread UFO sightings.